support@englishmadhyam.in +91 772-2987-077
Caste in jail: On discrimination in prisons
PDF
87
Caste in jail: On discrimination in prisonsTime for State governments to end systemic discrimination in prisonsThe most notable aspect of the Supreme Court ruling prohibiting caste-based discrimination in the treatment of prisoners is that it required a judgment from the highest court to end colonial practices and systems in prisons. While the Court has dealt elaborately with specific rules in the jail manuals of various States and the way in which caste-based hierarchy plays a role in allocation of duties, classification of prisoners, and the treatment of certain social groups as “habitual offenders”, it is quite remarkable that prison authorities and State governments had done so little about these aspects since independence. It is as if the prison system has been out of the reach of the core philosophy of the Constitution: the ushering in of an equal society, the ending of all forms of discrimination, the prohibition of untouchability in any form, and the abolition of forced labour and exploitation. Responding to journalist Sukanya Shantha’s writ petition, the Court has analysed the controversial rules and practices in jails in the backdrop of these constitutional objectives. It has ruled such provisions unconstitutional, and directed the revision of prison manuals within three months. Tracing the history of such rules and practices, the Court has noted, with much justification: “In line with their overall approach, the colonial administrators linked caste with prison administration of labour, food, and treatment of prisoners.”Not only were menial work and supposedly polluting occupations allocated to prisoners from communities placed lower in the caste hierarchy, some were expected to carry out their “hereditary trades” within prisons, the Court found. On the other hand, the caste privileges of a few placed higher were preserved. Few can disagree with the observation that “the notion that an occupation is considered as ‘degrading or menial’ is an aspect of the caste system and untouchability.” The provision that food must be cooked by prisoners from a “suitable caste” and rules that referred to those from the “scavenger class” being assigned tasks such as manual scavenging, sweeping, and cleaning violated the constitutional prohibition against untouchability. Distribution of labour cannot be solely based on birth. Such rules violate the right to dignity and the right against forced labour and exploitation. The Court has also favoured doing away with vague definitions of ‘habitual offenders’, as they seem to ascribe criminal tendencies to whole tribes, even though the idea of notifying ‘criminal tribes’ has long been given up. It is time for State governments to respond to the verdict and revisit their laws and regulations related to prison administration and put an end to systemic discrimination in an institution that may treat any form of resistance as indiscipline
SSC

-
Discrimination (noun) – Unfair treatment of a person or group on the basis of prejudice

भेदभाव

-

Systemic (adjective) – relating to or involving a whole system
प्रणालीगत

-
Notable (adjective) – noteworthy, remarkable, outstanding, important,

उल्लेखनीय

-
Aspect (noun) – A distinct feature or element

पहलू

-
Ruling (noun) – decision, judgment, decree

फ़ैसला

-

Prohibit (verb) – Ban, forbid, disallow, preclude, block

प्रतिबंधित करना

-

Colonial (adjective) – Imperial, relating to colonies, involving colonization, pre-independence

उपनिवेशकालीन

 

-

Deal with (phrasal verb) – handle, cope with, treat, manage,

निपटना, सुलझाना

-

Elaborately (adverb) – In detail, thoroughly, comprehensively, meticulously, exhaustively

विस्तारपूर्वक

 

-

Hierarchy (noun) – Ranking, order, gradation, ladder, scale,

पदानुक्रम

 

 

-

Allocation (noun) – distribution, allotment, apportionment, assignment

आवंटन

-
Offender (noun) – wrongdoer, criminal, lawbreaker, malefactor, felon,

अपराधी

-
Abolition (noun) – cancellation, repeal, annulment, elimination, destruction

उन्मूलन

-
Exploitation (noun) – Taking advantage, abuse, mistreatment

शोषण

-

Writ (noun) – Legal order, command, mandate, decree, injunction

रिट

 

-
Petition (noun) –appeal, request, application, याचिका

-

In the backdrop of (phrase) – Against the background of; in the circumstances of

के संदर्भ में

-

Direct (verb) – Guide, instruct, command, steer, lead

निर्देश देना

-

In line with (phrase) – According to, consistent with, in accordance with, following
के अनुसार

-

Administrator (noun) – Manager, director, executive, official, overseer

प्रशासक

 

-

Menial (adjective) – Lowly, degrading, servile, unskilled, trivial

छोटा/तुच्छ

 

-

Supposedly (adverb) – Allegedly, presumably, ostensibly, reportedly, apparently

कथित रूप से

-

Polluting (adjective) – Contaminating, corrupting, tainting, spoiling, defiling

भ्रष्ट

-

Occupation (noun) – Profession, job, work, career, employment

पेशा

 

-

Carry out (phrasal verb) – Execute, perform, implement, accomplish, undertake

करना

 

-

Hereditary (adjective) – Ancestral, familial, genetic, inherited, passed down

वंशानुगत

 

-

Privilege (noun) – advantage, benefit, entitlement, right, prerogative  

विशेषाधिकार

-
Preserve (verb) – Maintain, uphold, keep, continue, sustain, conserve 

बनाए रखना

-
Notion (noun) – idea, impression, thought, concept, opinion

धारणा

-

Scavenger (noun) – One who collects discarded items, forager, hunter, gatherer, recycler

कचरा बीनने वाला

 

-

Scavenging (noun) – Searching for discarded items, foraging, collecting, gathering, hunting

कचरा बीनना

-
Sweeping (adjective) – comprehensive, extensive, broad

व्यापक

-
Violate (verb) – breach, infringe, rape, break, transgress

उल्लंघन करना

-
Solely (adverb) –only, merely, just, exclusively, uniquely

केवल

-
Dignity (noun) – The quality of being worthy of esteem or respect 

गरिमा

-

Vague (adjective) – Unclear, indefinite, ambiguous, hazy, nebulous

अस्पष्ट

-

Ascribe (to) (verb) – Attribute, assign, credit, impute, refer to

जोड़ना

 

-
Tendency (noun) – inclination, propensity, likelihood

प्रवृत्ति

-

Give up (phrasal verb) – Surrender, abandon, relinquish, cede, forsake

त्यागना

-
Verdict (noun) – judgement, adjudication, adjudgement, decision

निर्णय

-

Revisit (verb) – reassess, re-evaluate, review, look over again

पुनर्विचार करना

-

Put an end to (phrasal verb) – Stop, terminate, abolish, conclude, finish

समाप्त करना

-

Resistance (noun) – Opposition, defiance, refusal, pushback

विरोध